I received a great response on the MoreTPRS Yahoo group to my
post about reading Pobre Ana with students that haven't ever had Spanish instruction before. This unexpected experience and subsequent comments have given me a few great insights!
First, I was able to clarify
why I want to read novels in class. What is my goal? Mainly, I want students to be able to simply read and understand stories. I want students to enjoy reading. And, most importantly, I want them to experience success. In describing her approach to reading novels, Susan Gross hit the nail on the head:
"I was ONLY aiming to make the kids love reading the book." - Susan Gross
That begs the question: What fosters this love of reading and what does not? Susan continues...
"That means the oNLY thing I was worried about was making sure they understood the story. Period. I was NOT trying to build vocabulary! I did not care that adjective placement is different or that this is an interesting idiom." - Susan Gross
"We did not do any enrichment or projects or quizzes or activities. The first few years of doing novels I did a whole bunch of experiments doing projects and clever little assignments for each chapter, stuff like that. And I had a comparison with just reading as much and as fast as we could (keeping it enjoyable and talking about things that sparked an interest in the class, but only a couple of minutes here and there.) I tried as hard as I could to make it like my own pleasure reading: I NEVER stop to think of a title for each chapter or try to match characters with dialog or take a quiz! I just read because I enjoy the book. That was my goal with the novels: reading for fluency. That means no evaluations, no quizzes, just read it and enjoy it!" - Susan Gross
So, did this actually achieve her goals?
"The results of many experiments always came out the same: Reading for pleasure beat every single activity or enrichment. So why would I want to work so hard? Why would I want to give kids quizzes? Heck, let's just read the book and laugh our fools heads off. Kids so fell in love with reading that they used to check out books fro my French library all of the time! Not just for free reading in class time, but to take home and read! Even kids who were 'non-readers' who swore that they hated reading wound up checking out books to read over the weekend." - Susan Gross
That sounds like exactly what I want to achieve! As a kid, I was able to develop a love for reading and believe my language skills are a direct result of that. If students are able to simply love what they're doing and be successful, they'll continue to learn more beyond my classroom! If not, then we are fighting a losing battle:
"Remember, my ONLY concern is getting kids to fall in love with French. And I used the novels to make them fall in love with reading French. Writing words on the board, making charts and lists of words, fill in blanks, put events in order, stuff like that does not contribute to reading enjoyment. If it did, then I would do those things every time I pick up a novel here at home. All the extraneous things that teachers do to books are "teacher things." They are not reading and they do not make kids WANT to read. We never do stuff like that at my book club, and I tried to make class as much like my book club as possible! Keep your focus on just that one thing and you will get it going right." - Susan Gross
Scott Benedict echoed this sentiment:
"I never did well with all of those reading activities and treating these books as literature. I read them for the cultural content and for language acquisition. If we continue to make reading a chore, we will continue to be a nation of non-readers. We must change this! " - Scott Benedict
So what activities and clarification
do work? Susan describes when she would step in:
"When something came up that needed clarification, I clarified. NOT because I was the fount of knowledge, NOT because I wanted them to stop enjoying the story to look at vocab, NOT because of anything other than 'This needs to be clarified in order to understand what is going on and to enjoy the story!'" - Susan Gross
Expanding on this some, I do believe that class discussion of the book is beneficial and powerful, but only as it adds authentic meaning and clarification to the book, rather than an imposition of a meaningless "here's what you need to get from this" activity. Susan suggested what this type of discussion might look like:
"As for discussion, try to discuss in Spanish. But if what you have to say is too complicated, then do it in English. Or ask a question in English and in Spanish like this "Do any of you know a person like Ana?" "¿Conocen Uds. a una persona como Ana?" The kids will answer in English most likely but if it can be put into comprehensible Spanish, then do so. The important thing is to enjoy the story and to laugh about it. So maybe you ask if Barney the Dinosaur is like Ana. Things like that. Make it fun and then get back to reading the book." - Susan Gross
Mira Canion identified why teaching background information leading up to the book and continued discussion of these things while reading plays a critical role in reading novels:
"Reading a novel in a second language is different than reading a simple short story that was created by a class. There are layers of meaning. Background knowledge about historical events, cultural references, etc., plays a much bigger role in successful reading of a novel than in reading simple stories. Knowing vocabulary is only part of the comprehension puzzle. Keeping the plot, characters, and background information straight competes with vocabulary recognition. It is important that students be able to visualize what they read. Too much unfamiliar vocabulary and lack of background knowledge can make visualization very difficult. It is very helpful to choose the right level reading. ... So, consider reading a book that is very comprehensible so that all students have a chance at being successful. Then have other readings that explore the themes and background of the novel." - Mira Canion
She also suggested mixing up the format in which we read the novel, and I particularly liked how she described these activities as creating a "shared experience":
"My favorite way to read novels is to help students visualize the plot by acting it out much like a tprs story. I also like to mix in silent readings of the text with a few deep comprehension questions or have the students draw the main action. My students love to be able to read a novel and act it out because reading becomes a shared experience." - Mira Canion
However, it should be pointed out that, just because you aren't focusing on vocabulary or structures, this doesn't mean students aren't learning them. In fact, just the opposite - as demonstrated by my experience with the student reading Pobre Ana, she was learning vocabulary and how the language was put together by simply reading it with me and nothing more. I can't remember where I saw it, but I recently read a quote which indicated that the best way for anyone to acquire incidental vocabulary is through reading - and that's exactly what's happening when we read with our students.
Moreover, students are motivated when we guarantee success. In reference to my experience with the student I read with, Susan said:
"It is our job to guarantee success. If a child does not know something and we do not provide the meaning of the word, then we are making the kid feel dumb. The kid will eventually retaliate against us with hostility, refusal to go along with our wishes, attempts to do something different, getting off-topic, etc etc etc. When we guarantee success, we invite the kids to show how great they are. We translate for them and just ask them to do the words they know." - Susan Gross
Then, she described how this looks in her classroom and the atmosphere it creates:
"Now can you imagine how it looked in my classroom when one kid was doing a paragraph? Was I looking around for misbehavior? No! I was reading with the kid, just a few words ahead and anytime the kid paused, even just to catch his breath, I was right there, saying the next word for him. He just kept on reading and the whole paragraph was read smoothly, with no hesitation. Whether he paused to swallow or cough or because he didn't know the word was of NO IMPORTANCE. The only thing that mattered was that we were reading and enjoying the story line. Just like when I read for pleasure. I just keep gong even when the author uses a word I am unsure of! So I made that same atmosphere in my classroom." - Susan Gross
She goes on to answer the question that was bound to come up:
"Do I make sure everyone translates? What if a kid does not want to do it? I think you already know the answer, but I will answer the question with a question: Does forcing a kid do something against his will make the novel more interesting/exciting/fun?" - Susan Gross
Powerful words! (Why does it seem that so many teachers are blind to this?)
Both Scott and Susan also had excellent comments on
how to to incorporate reading novels in the classroom, and I'm sold. Susan reiterated the insight I had based on reading Pobre Ana with a student without any Spanish: I don't necessarily need to teach everything necessary for students to read the leveled novella readers on their own - they're already ready to dive right in with proper guidance:
"Students do not need to 'get ready' for it; they can be successful right away in the first quarter." - Susan Gross
So the question would be when to schedule it in along with all the other activities we do. While the Look, I can talk! teacher guides lay out a plan that includes novel reading once per week, it would take an entire semester to read a book. That doesn't sit well with me. Instead, I originally planned on reading a chapter or so each week, completing one novel each quarter, but I can see how that would get pushed aside and dragged out. As Scott describes:
"I never liked the read once a week thing as it always drew out the stories too long and both myself and my students lost interest." - Scott Benedict
Another idea would be to read it all at once, which I am coming back to after being dissatisfied with how weekly novella reading was working with my preliminary curriculum planning. I'd still do one book per quarter, but set aside two weeks for each one. That's plenty of time to read a chapter or two each day and be very thorough, yet make progress fast enough to experience continuity. Plus, there are a few extra benefits:
"I used to end each quarter with a novel. So I taught 7 weeks of TPRS/culture and then two weeks to zoom through a novel. We just picked up the novel and started translating. In ten days (two weeks) we were done with the book! And during those ten days, I made sure that everybody had all of their work made up so I had no catching up to do after the grading period." - Susan Gross
Now, wouldn't that be nice? Two weeks off of formal teaching for me and my students leading up to the end of the grading period, and more effective in the first place! It's a match made in heaven - and I think this is the path I want to take. I also don't have to worry about whether I've taught the structures for the books - students will spend the first 7 weeks acquiring, acquiring, and acquiring more, so they should be able to understand quite a bit of the book on their own no matter what structures we've done. That frees me up to select my structures based on more repetitive materials (I'm going back to the LICT stories) that facilitate acquisition, and then allows students to recognize and apply them in a broader, less repetitive context.
For me, this works particularly well as I'll be grading notebooks (and students won't have their notebooks) at the end of the quarter as well as facilitating any re-takes students want to do. Instead of worrying about new material, students and I can focus on getting where we need to be with the material we've worked on all quarter/semester, ready to begin a new one.
As Susan mentioned, fostering this love of reading will also encourage to read on their own, which I plan to do through free-choice reading of a set amount of time each week. Mira touched on this briefly:
"Combine a class novel with student choice. Let students choose their own novel to read independently. They can journal or write about how they connect to the character or plot." - Mira Canion
Yay for collaboration!