In my
last post, I discussed how it seems that reading had been given a death sentence, particularly with high school students. So what do we do now?
I believe that there are two main goals for reading, and they will dictate the route to reviving reading for our students.
- Reading for information
- Reading for language
Regardless of the purpose or goal for reading, there are a few things that each of these routes have in common. First and foremost, the text must be comprehensible. There is no point in reading if students cannot create meaning from what is being read. Second, interest is critical. We are all fully (and often painfully) aware that a student that is unwilling to learn cannot be taught, but that a student determined to learn cannot be stopped. Likewise, a student that is unwilling to read cannot be forced to truly do so, but a student that is determined to read will succeed. Even when the reading level is beyond a student's ability, a student determined to read and learn will find a way to do so. If we are able to foster interest in our students, reading will follow.
Reading for Information
First, let's tackle reading for information. This is the purpose of reading in many subjects. Realistically, most informational texts are not going to be read from cover to cover. Rather, we use various tools (like the Table of Contents or, my personal favorite, "search" function in electronic texts) to sift out the exact information we're looking for. The other information will only be read if it is of interest to the reader or if it seems relevant to the task at hand. Rather than forcing students to read an entire text they most likely will not take meaning from anyway, shouldn't we be teaching effective skills for finding this information? Moreover, in the real world, students will most often not be given a specific text or source in the first place, but rather have to find their own reliable sources of information (in the case that they do have "required" reading, it will be in the career of their choice and I would assume their paycheck will be much more persuasive than a letter grade). In today's technology- and information-infused age, shouldn't we focus on teaching them how to find reliable sources of information hidden within the countless resources students now have at their fingertips, or in their pockets? Moreover, this would allow students to select the articles of most interest to them, and together the students and teachers can evaluate and critique the information as it pertains to the task at hand. Wouldn't this prepare students for real-world situations and requirements?
In addition to allowing student to select their resources for information, we could also facilitate better comprehension and the opportunity for growth by providing students resources with a broad range of reading levels. Even a more complex text can be simplified by hi-lighting and/or annotating the most important information so student's get lost in. A library of resources on a broad range of subjects relating to the class and of various reading levels could be provided for students to find information as well as free-choice reading. The teacher still has control over where the information is coming from, while providing student opportunities for students to select the resource of most interest and comprehensibility to them. Even the highest readers could benefit from a library such as this which could include even articles from recognized Journals, which they will be asked to comprehend throughout college and, sometimes, their chosen careers. Such a library encourages students to become active in their own learning and discover the joy of reading for learning information of value to them.
Finally, even the most boring textbook can be made interesting if read with the zeal and frenzy of a mad scientist. (Of course, that also begs the question of 'why is the text boring? Are the students understanding what the words even mean?) Students' impression of subject matter highly depends on how the teacher presents it. I assume you don't think your subject is boring, so why give your students the chance to think so? Whatever happened to reading a text out loud? And, when we do read out loud, is it always the best idea for students to be the ones reading out loud to the rest of the class in a monotone suck-the-life-out voice the best way the material could be presented? And, anyway, isn't more effective and meaningful for you (or a student) to put it in their own words? Isn't that what investigation and presentation is all about - finding the information from experts, creating meaning from it, and then re-wording it in the most effective way?
Reading for language
So, when should students actually be required to read a text word-for-word? It's simple, and the research backs it up: Reading improves language. It's builds vocabulary and strengthens grammatical forms. As my mission is to teach language, this is where reading is not only necessary, but critical. However, if I provide reading that is incomprehensible or of little interest to students, I will fail entirely. Thus, we have the (re)birth of reading. Starting from square one, since that is where my students generally are, I need to select texts the way that elementary teachers have done so well. Required texts are not selected by the reading level at which they are written with subject matter that captivates the story-hungry child within all of us. In addition, students are guided and supported throughout the reading. Beyond required reading, students should be provided with opportunities to read based on personal interest and choice. A library of Spanish books including everything from Dr. Seuss to Harry Potter as well as links to interesting articles and websites online are priceless resources in my classroom. Students often take joy in re-reading a story they often heard as children and discovering they can also read it in another language. Higher-level students take pride in being able to decode what the words mean and understanding more complex ideas embedded in the text.
Ultimately, nothing motivates like success. So let's begin helping students experience success in reading - and the rest will follow.